Hidden Gem Psychological Horror Games
Highly rated Psychological Horror games that never got big: under $20, fewer than 25,000 reviews. The review cap filters out everything you've already heard of.
All Indie Action Adventure Simulation RPG Strategy Co-op Open World Story Rich Casual Funny Survival Difficult Pixel Graphics PvP Horror Anime Puzzle Rogue-like Relaxing Turn-Based Strategy Local Co-Op Psychological Horror Hack and Slash Platformer MMO RTS Immersive Sim Post-apocalyptic Action Roguelike City Builder Life Sim Zombies Sports Racing Survival Horror Stealth Bullet Hell Dungeon Crawler Visual Novel JRPG Deckbuilding Grand Strategy Cyberpunk Tower Defense Clicker Fighting Open World Survival Craft Boomer Shooter Colony Sim Farming Sim Cozy Auto Battler Cooking Twin Stick Shooter Metroidvania 4X Souls-like Dating Sim MMORPG
By price
Our score adjusts Steam's raw rating for sample size. The fewer reviews a game has, the more its score gets pulled toward the site-wide average, so a tiny game can't fluke its way to #1.
- 1The Room Two21,44993.70%97.58%
- 2Fran Bow22,26793.67%97.39%
- 3Nubby's Number Factory18,57793.25%97.49%
- 4Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk21,64793.10%96.66%
- 5Outcore: Desktop Adventure17,87893.09%97.39%
- 6Cruelty Squad23,59692.98%96.20%
- 7The Test20,13192.97%96.74%
- 8Tales of the Black Forest15,22592.77%97.61%
- 9Zup! S15,95792.41%96.82%
- 10Darkwood24,32392.15%94.93%
- 11missed messages.15,48191.88%96.07%
- 12Cube Escape: Paradox11,86391.72%97.05%
- 13Night in the Woods19,97391.66%94.79%
- 14Pony Island17,99891.56%94.99%
- 15Find Love or Die Trying11,96791.52%96.63%
- 16LISA: The Painful15,03891.44%95.46%
- 17Samsara Room10,02191.29%97.18%
- 18Living With Sister: Monochrome Fantasy11,78691.25%96.22%
- 19Impostor Factory12,65291.20%95.80%
- 20The Past Within16,52891.19%94.71%
- 21NGU IDLE12,78391.18%95.62%
- 22Kindergarten10,27591.18%96.81%
- 23The Room Three13,19591.15%95.51%
- 24Detention11,71890.93%95.65%
- 25F.E.A.R.19,10990.84%93.69%
- 26Cat Goes Fishing16,10590.80%94.16%
- 27Rusty Lake Hotel10,26190.80%96.06%
- 28Turnip Boy Commits Tax Evasion13,82990.76%94.65%
- 29Five Nights at Freddy's: Into the Pit10,81290.73%95.67%
- 30Five Nights at Freddy's 416,65290.08%92.90%
- 31Insaniquarium Deluxe6,68289.97%96.83%
- 32Yuppie Psycho: Executive Edition9,22689.96%94.91%
- 33The Test: Hypothesis Rising5,92689.94%97.60%
- 34Yume Nikki10,17189.86%94.25%
- 35KinitoPET14,37789.86%92.96%
- 36Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion15,42689.80%92.66%
- 37Cyber Manhunt15,49389.77%92.60%
- 38The Test: Final Revelation5,37189.75%97.88%
- 39Nothing9,84989.74%94.16%
- 40DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition12,78589.73%93.12%
- 41Mount Your Friends7,67189.71%95.35%
- 42Class of '098,64789.67%94.62%
- 43Zup!8,90689.52%94.15%
- 44Psychopomp GOLD5,04489.46%97.52%
- 45The Exit 810,97189.46%93.16%
- 46The Supper4,38689.42%98.61%
- 47Little Misfortune13,75889.40%92.32%
- 48Rakuen5,91689.38%96.13%
- 49Quaver16,72389.36%91.74%
- 50Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald: A Whirlwind Heist10,11889.34%93.25%
- 51The Swapper7,54289.20%94.11%
- 52DRAMAtical Murder4,70789.01%96.71%
- 53POSTAL13,90088.98%91.55%
- 54We Were Here Forever18,25688.89%90.81%
- 55Chicory: A Colorful Tale3,94188.87%97.41%
- 56Papa's Pizzeria Deluxe3,53688.87%98.70%
- 57Choo-Choo Charles17,15488.86%90.89%
- 58Pathologic 212,02988.82%91.68%
- 59BOKURA12,63288.81%91.52%
- 60Oxenfree12,07788.71%91.45%
- 61AI: The Somnium Files9,23688.38%91.61%
- 62POSTAL Redux7,97388.31%91.97%
- 63Seen9,95988.27%91.15%
- 64港詭實錄ParanormalHK20,17688.14%89.50%
- 65House of Detention10,62988.12%90.70%
- 66Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location12,51488.02%90.12%
- 67Jump King13,20987.97%89.92%
- 68Five Nights at Freddy's 311,16687.95%90.24%
- 69Miss Neko 34,70087.82%93.00%
- 70Duck Simulator 22,87087.81%95.85%
- 71INMOST7,25587.67%90.81%
- 72Dark Deception23,61087.62%88.56%
- 73WORLD OF HORROR9,77387.56%89.78%
- 74Max Payne15,62387.52%88.88%
- 75The Song of Saya9,56287.51%89.73%
- 76RATSHAKER3,67687.50%93.23%
- 77Her Story10,31387.41%89.37%
- 78The Beginner's Guide23,03587.37%88.23%
- 79Gaokao.Love.100Days8,20987.35%89.73%
- 80Mister Furry: Hot Muscles4,30487.33%91.82%
- 81Paunch11,30287.31%89.00%
- 82The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes10,60587.20%88.91%
- 83Fast Food Simulator9,30587.12%88.97%
- 84Carpe Diem8,55187.10%89.10%
- 85Open World Game: the Open World Game2,53586.91%92.90%
- 86Monstrum3,70886.80%90.61%
- 87Copycat5,38986.71%89.14%
- 88FPV Kamikaze Drone12,32986.69%87.75%
- 89Grunn1,34986.69%96.29%
- 90Matchmaking Inc.7,00086.64%88.41%
- 91Walking Simulator9,45786.61%87.90%
- 92Nunholy5,16986.61%88.97%
- 93Receiver 23,02086.61%90.63%
- 94Breakout 137,42086.50%88.01%
- 95That's not my Neighbor4,43486.43%88.77%
- 96I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream3,80786.36%88.92%
- 97Catherine Classic10,99386.33%87.19%
- 98Cooking Companions1,19386.29%93.80%
- 99Murky Divers5,23086.22%87.80%
- 100I Can't Believe It's Not Gambling1,66786.21%91.12%
